Since this date, getting patent protection became harder. Now, the first inventor to file a patent application will be recognized as the inventor of this
So is now the right time for a resurgence of copyright applications for software to protect intellectual property rights? Yes, perhaps. While copyrights cannot replace patents as a legal monopoly, for the smaller business or entrepreneur with limited funding and wanting a quick certification of ownership, copyright offers a simple, cost-effective solution.
Unlike patents (which protect innovative ideas), copyrights only protect the particular expression of an idea, such as a story, or a software application. There is some room for additional copyright protection against plagiarized “derivative” works, but not much, since the author of the “derivative” work need only show a minimal level of originality to defeat a claim of plagiarism.
But, copyrights still have a lot of value. A copyright owner can prevent others from copying and marketing clone software or even a clone product catalog. You don’t need to register to own the copyright, but registration helps with enforcement. The owner of a registered
U.S. copyright can sue for damages
and collect attorney’s fees. (Owners of
trade secrets can only sue for damages and normally cannot collect attorneys’
fees). And you can register the
copyright with U.S.
customs authorities to prevent the importation of infringing products. All this is a powerful incentive for
preventing knock-offs. The U.S. online
copyright filing fee is only $35 per basic claim of authorship.
But, done wrong, registering a copyright can risk losing trade secret and/or patent rights. If you deposit a copy of your source code for the app with the U.S. Copyright Office, it risks making public your confidential secret sauce, which would normally defeat trade secrecy and could endanger an unfiled patent application. Done right, however, your copyright registration can avoid that risk by careful planning and limited disclosure of the secret sauce.
Your copyright registration program should fit within a more holistic overall program to protect intellectual property including trade secrets. The copyright deposit materials could be machine-readable object code, so that it becomes indecipherable without an operating system and a computer language. Or the deposit materials could be fractions of a printout of the code. All you need to do is prove that it compiles, and do it in a manner that prevents anyone from decoding. Special rules apply, though, for apps that are derivative works or include some open-source components.
For low-cost and high legal value, copyright registration may become the method of choice for entrepreneurs and small app developers. Patents should still be pursued as a defensive measure, but copyrights can be an important part of the plan.